In reality, what’s degrading is not sex work itself, but the language [prohibitionists use] to describe it. – Joyce Arthur
This coming Tuesday is The International Day to End Violence Against Sex Workers, and Siouxsie Q has compiled a list of events (some of which will be held tomorrow). Take a look, and please consider participating if you live in any of these cities.
[A court ruled that] a [New Zealand] man who promised to financially support a prostitute…won’t be able to get back $500,000 he gave her…He…met…[her] at a massage parlour in…late 2007…and suggested…that he would support her financially…[if] she…[gave] up work…[he paid her] $5000 a month and…lavished her with money, travel and various gifts…
A D.C. police officer is being investigated for allegedly “pimping” teenage girls…Linwood Barnhill, 47, was found with a girl who had been reported missing…Neighbors [said] they would often see young girls going in and out of his apartment…this investigation is not connected to the…arrest of another D.C. police officer on child porn charges. In that case, officer Marc Washington…went to the home of a 15-year-old girl…ordered her to remove her clothing and took photos of her…
And in Arizona: “A Maricopa County juvenile probation officer is accused of running an illegal massage business ‘providing acts of prostitution’…apartment resident Ashley Martinez [said] ‘It could be bringing in pedophiles…and my kids could be getting caught into that’…” The jaw-droppingly stupid quote from the imbecilic neighbor was too good to omit.
Apparently, American courts hate oil companies more than whores:
BP has…been forced to pay hundreds of millions of dollars to businesses that filed damage claims after the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill disaster – even though they weren’t really affected…the court-appointed [supervisor] has confirmed he approved a $173,000 payout to an “adult escort service” that BP said was filed with unsigned and undated financial documents…The company contested the escort service payment…but lost before a court-appointed appeals panel…
For Those Who Think Legalization is a Good Idea (October Updates)
As police go on strike in Argentina’s second largest city…the people have…[looted] every supermarket…the governor of Cordoba…claims that the police strike is a direct result of his decision to close 140 brothels…which had provided a steady income stream to a large number of corrupt officers…
A [newlywed] couple…lured a man to his death with an ad on…Craigslist…because they wanted to kill someone together…Elytte Barbour told officers…that he and his wife, Miranda…[lured] Troy LaFerrara…[with an escort] posting…Elytte [said]…Miranda…regularly…made anywhere from $50 to $850 by meeting with men for such activities as having dinner together or walking around a mall. The ads she placed…all said upfront that sex was not part of the deal…”She is not a prostitute…she…meets with them and has delightful conversation”…
I’m sure that conversation is wholly delightful. Somebody want to tell Elytte the Simpleton that the majority of American escort ads say “upfront” that no sex is involved? NB: This is the second time we’ve seen a deranged hooker expecting people to believe she truly doesn’t have sex with clients.
Panicked policy reactions to human trafficking and an over-emphasis on the issue of sex trafficking can cause more harm than good…trafficking expert…Pardis Mahdavi said…“Policies are made as a knee-jerk reaction based on moral panic…People like to put distance between themselves and the sex industry, whereas…the domestic workers who clean our homes, the nannies who care for our children, the people who pick the tomatoes that we eat, these are often people who are involved in forced labour…over ninety percent of trafficking is not in the sex industry, it’s forced labour…”
A peek inside the mind of a bureaucrat:
…Of the 50,000 T-visas that have been offered over the last 10 years, the government has issued only 6,206 of the little-known visas meant to protect victims of human trafficking and their family members…despite the fact that between 14,500 and 17,500 people are trafficked into the U.S. every year…those who apply…have to be willing to testify against the traffickers…and…are not allowed to work while waiting for the visa, which can take a year or more…
Of course the estimate can’t possibly be wrong, and asking people to live without income for a year is perfectly reasonable. The FBI claims “authorities would assist victims, even if there is not a trafficker who can be prosecuted,” but that’s clearly bullshit; the whole “trafficking” narrative depends on producing “traffickers”.
Observable fact: 14-year-old girl runs away with her 19-year-old boyfriend. Conclusion: a giant worldwide conspiracy selling infants for snuff sex:
The search for Elizabeth Romero and her alleged kidnapper Edwardo Fabian Flores Rosales continues…officials believe that the duo have already crossed the border into Mexico…Some people believe that she is voluntarily…with the 19-year-old man she met on the internet…others believe that…[she] could…be the victim of sex trafficking…Children as young as infants are…wrangled up from every corner of the globe and herded from one master to the next…as sex slaves until they are “used up”…which usually ends in their murders…the scenario of this 14-year-old girl being a willing runaway is far easier to stomach than the idea of her being sold for unimaginable sex acts and then killed…
It’s hard to see how this lurid fantasy can be called “unimaginable” when the author is clearly able to imagine it.
Another good article from Joyce Arthur, this on language used by the media. While I myself use some of the terms she advises against, that’s only in an informal and personal context; I think she is correct in advising use of more neutral terms in mainstream articles.
A [New York] attorney…argued that his defendant’s hefty sentence for murdering a transgender woman should be reserved for someone who kills “certain classes of individuals”…Rasheen Everett was convicted of the 2010 murder of Amanda Gonzalez-Andujar, a transgender prostitute…but…defense attorney John Scarpa…argued…”Shouldn’t that [sentence] be reserved for people who are guilty of killing certain classes of individuals?…Who is the victim in this case? Is the victim a person in the higher end of the community?”…Justice Richard Buchter…[replied] “This court believes every human life in sacred…It’s not easy living as a transgender, and I commend the family for supporting her”…
There’s probably an entire research paper on the Jungian implications of yellow journalists describing anything to do with sex as “dark”: “Korea has long been criticized for its lax control over its…entertainer visa…exploited by human traffickers to smuggle foreign women into the country to do sex work. Authorities…promised to strengthen monitoring of the seedy establishments where the women have been forced to sell sex…” The evidence presented for this supposed epidemic of “trafficking”? US government propaganda and a supposed phone call from one anonymous informant who claims to have been a “victim”.
An Example to the West (TW3 #324)
The Bolivian Parliament is preparing a new law to regulate and recognize sex work…This is the result of an initiative by Organización de Trabajadoras Nocturnas (OTN)…to prevent “the physical and psychological abuse and discrimination” suffered by sex workers from police and nightclub owners…
That’ll show them dirty photographers! See the last line for the police motive.
Authorities have shut down Hong Kong’s largest prostitution website…sex141.com…was believed to have been controlled by a criminal syndicate, which police say they have now broken up. “When they knew there were sex workers coming to Hong Kong, the syndicate would arrange a make-up service and photographers,” a police spokesman [said]…While prostitution is legal in Hong Kong, soliciting and living off the earnings of prostitutes are against the law…114 people have been arrested, which includes 78 prostitutes…arrested on such charges as overstaying or violating the conditions of their visitor visa. Police also said about HK$15 million ($1.93 million) worth of assets related to the group had been frozen…
I know real people are endangered by this idiocy, but I just can’t help laughing every time “authorities” pretend that North Dakota is a “sex trafficking hub”:
U.S. Sen. Heidi Heitkamp has introduced legislation…to crack down on sex trafficking, which experts fear is on the rise in…North Dakota due to the large influx of men coming to work in the state’s western oil patch…”North Dakota could be ground zero for this type of behavior,” Heitkamp…said…
The only thing that keeps me from adding that claim to “King of the Hill” is that they use qualifiers like “fear” and “could be” rather than stating it as a “fact”.
Whatever They Need To Say (TW3 #341)
New excuses for another Soho pogrom:
Hundreds of police officers launched a massive Soho swoop on premises allegedly linked to rape, sex trafficking and muggings…22 people were arrested in the raids on…premises suspected of being…fronts for handling stolen goods…a dozen women…were taken to safe locations where they will be questioned. Police believe that some were trafficked into the country and forced into prostitution…The English Collective of Prostitutes…condemned the raids saying some “immigrant women were taken into custody on the pretext that they may be victims of trafficking, despite their protestations that they were not…police are raiding premises where women are working together safely…with friends…most of the women…have now lost their livelihood”…
Nikki Adams from the ECP…[called] it…an “outrageous fabrication”, adding: “At least two of those women I know well and they’ve been in the UK for years and speak perfect English and come to all our meetings…People fear that the evictions are aimed at making way for large-scale development”…
A press release from Sex Worker Open University added, “The media presence included Sky news, BBC and the Evening Standard. It would seem that ‘victims’ of sex work need to be publicly humiliated and shamed…in order to be properly saved from their work…”
It’s not a “front for prostitution”, it is prostitution. However, note the equation of sex with rape; cops and prosecutors imagine everyone to be as twisted and evil as they are:
…For $60, customers at the Snuggle House can spend an hour hugging, cuddling and spooning with professional snugglers…but Madison officials suspect the business is a front for prostitution and…fear snuggling could lead to sexual assault…police have talked…about conducting a sting…and city attorneys are drafting a new ordinance to regulate snuggling. “There’s no way that (sexual assault) will not happen”…city attorney Jennifer Zilavy said. “No offense…but I don’t know any man who wants to just snuggle”…
More from Frank Furedi on the myth of “modern slavery”:
…promoters of this urban legend about modern-day slavery [argue] that what is really significant about this hitherto unrecognised crime is not what can be seen by the naked eye but rather the often “invisible” problem of mental enslavement. These are slaves who are not physically chained into a life of servitude, but rather are wrapped up in “emotional chains” by their psychologically manipulative captors. [A term like] “brainwashed”…can transform even normal features of human life – such as being in an unpleasant relationship or feeling pressured to do something – into something…criminal…Such an exercise in rhetorical acrobatics allows campaigners to expand the number of “invisible slaves”…
And yes, he does mention Kevin Bales’ “30 million slaves”.
The American media would have you believe Alice Schwarzer’s revolting demand for imposition of the Swedish model on Germany has widespread support, but here’s a more typical German view of her:
Alice Schwarzer is an enemy of freedom. She is condescending, she’s manipulative, she does not tolerate contradiction and therefore has no sense of what makes people, in all their contradictions, essentially human…She loves to divide the world into good and evil, victim and perpetrator…she has a Manichean world view, especially with regard to human sexuality…this…leads to very unpleasant consequences in the debate about prostitution…in [her mind] there is no room for autonomous, free men and…women…who decide…what they want…
Sex work can be quite traumatizing to say the least but hey, who am I to judge… behind every career there is a story. Indeed, looks can be deceiving and the most beautiful bodies may have the biggest scars on the inside.
Technical note on the Der Spiegel article linked to via Google Translate: for those who don’t know a lot of German, Google Translate did a very literal translation of the name Schwarzer into Black (schwarz means black in German). But it’s also inconsistently translating it as such so sometimes the name appears as it should in German. Just wanted to point that out should someone wonder who the hell Black is and why they randomly appeared in the article. Some other inconsistencies in the translation that I could see but not enough to diminish the article.
Thanks so much Maggie for quoting me and mentioning my article 🙂
The Der Spiegel article was great but didn’t translate too well. I think Google Translate has trouble with cleverly-written stuff. A few things were incomprehensible – eg, what’s a “Federstreich”? Google didn’t know but “trick of the pen” is my best guess for the context.
Great article by Frank Furedi too. I really like his term “moral entrepreneurs.” Unfortunately he’s right that there’s some kind of strong emotional appeal to believing in alleged hidden horrors like slavery, instead of actual serious injustices in front of your face.
I think we’re seeing some word play here with Federstreich. The usual word is Federstrich, a ‘stroke of the pen’; the ‘streich’ might well mean ‘trick’ or ‘prank’; but ‘streich’ can also be used to refer to a ‘hooker’ or ‘whore’.
The idea of “moral entrepreneurs” is an important idea in moral panic theory, which Furedi as a sociologist is clearly referencing. More here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_entrepreneur
As usual, you’ve hit the nail exactly dead center on the head.
And, by the way, on a cold day with a snowstorm outside, $60 for an hour of cuddling sounds warm, good, and not really overpriced, either. Sure glad the porktards are constantly on the alert, protecting me and mine from the possibility that two snugglers somewhere might take it into their heads to make a further voluntary arrangement. Oh, the horrors!
Professional cuddlers are an excellent deal. The ones whose pictures I’ve seen are really hot, and they offer an hour of full contact for less than I’ve seen thoroughly unattractive women charge for fifteen-minute lays on Backpage.
I appreciate their demureness, too, since I’ve had some experiences with women who were far too vulgar and weird for my tastes. I don’t care to get sexual with women who shriek and curse like they’re on a porn set and can’t maintain a remotely normal affect the moment we start fucking; been there, done that, and I try to give it a wide berth. Pornographic tropes have lodged too deeply into some hookers’ minds, and I’ve read that they can be a huge problem with amateur girls, too. One of the big reasons that I prefer going to masseuses is that massage culture overrides this nonsense with much more sensible and, IMO, sexier standards of behavior. Similarly, I’d rather cuddle with a woman who’s sexually conservative but engaging and sane than get laid with a woman who’s too shrill to be at all intimate.
What I can’t tell about the sexual attitudes and boundaries of these professional cuddlers is whether they’re sanely conservative, coquettish, repressed, or what. I came across one whose FAQ page includes an offer to switch to big spoon if her client has a “natural reaction.” Resorting to a euphemism like that for an erection seems awfully immature for a grown woman whose line of work inevitably involves prolonged physical intimacy with sexually aroused men. On the other hand, these women are making every effort to desexualize their businesses so that government busybodies will stop bothering them, so stipulations like that may serve well enough as legal fig leaves and guidelines for clients who would otherwise push the envelope.
Some of the pick-up artist/”manosphere” blogs (e.g., Chateau Heartiste) have laid into these cuddling services as cruel schemes run by frigid feminist teases to blue-ball beta males. These guys are cultists who encourage audiences of shut-ins to get laid by approaching strange women cold in bars, and some of them have a longstanding antipathy to whores in general for being impediments to learning “game.” It says a lot about their character that they tell socially marginal men to try to manipulate nutty amateur bar hangers-on for sex instead of hiring professionals.
Schwarzer has long been a sort of part-Dworkin, part-Steinem figure in Germany, perhaps best known for her silly campaigns against photographer Helmut Newton. Unfortunately, the European Social Democrats taking up anti-sex work feminism as part of their platform has taken creeps like Schwarzer out of the margins.
Although it all happened 50 years ago, there has been a revival of interest in the ‘Profumo Affair’ and the trial of Stephen Ward; there are moves under way to get his convictions overturned.
Lord Denning (a senior judge) was asked to report on the security aspects of the affair. His use of language makes it subtly clear in his report where his sympathies lie. He always refers to ‘Mr Profumo’ or ‘Mr JD Profumo’; but it’s ‘Stephen Ward’ or just ‘Ward’, and ‘Christine Keeler’ or ‘Christine’.
He also refers to a photograph of Miss Keeler in a bikini, published in a Sunday newspaper. “I mention this photograph because most people seeing it would readily infer the avocation of Christine Keeler.”
“At least two of those women I know well and they’ve been in the UK for years and speak perfect English ”
An admission that just like all of these other moral panics, it’s basically about racism.
[…] and the woman the follower. But from the moment I read this report, I strongly suspected that this time it was the wife who was the psychopath and the husband her weak-willed assistant. Why? Because she actually expected him to believe […]